_edited_edited.png)
What is Subrogation?
Subrogation
You might need medical treatment before you get money from the person who caused the accident if you're involved in an accident. Typically, your insurance company will cover the treatment. Subrogation is a legal term that basically means your insurance company can collect the money it paid out to you for your injury, but only from the person who caused it.
A subrogation payment comes from the compensatory damages that are paid by the other party's insurance company in your personal injury lawsuit. Subrogation applies to payments you receive from your insurance provider relating to: Medical Payments (Med-Pay), Uninsured Motorist Coverage, Workers' Compensation, and Health Insurance. You may only receive subrogation payments from your insurance company if you have been injured. Civ. Code 3040, California’s “Made Whole” Doctrine, and The Common Fund Doctrine.
Subrogation
As part of a personal injury claim, a victim sues the party who caused her harm to recover damages for her losses. Accident victims are often compensated by their own insurance companies or other providers before they receive money from the person at fault. Treatment may be provided by a hospital, medical treatment through her own health insurance, medical treatment through another insurance policy, lost wages through another insurance plan, or other benefits. Accident victims should be responsible for any benefits they receive before the end of their lawsuit.
Subrogation is a process by which companies that make these first payments are eventually reimbursed by the person who is at fault. According to the dictionary, subrogation is the right of an insurance company to recover money from the person who caused the accident for the damages it paid out. As the insurer, the insurance company has the right to pursue recovery from the person responsible for the accident. The insurance company takes over the rights of the accident victim. The insurance company takes the place of the accident victim when it agrees to pay the accident victim money and can be reimbursed by the person who caused the accident.
An insurance company's right to subrogation is derived from the rights of the accident victim. The insurance company has the same rights as the person who caused the accident as the accident victim, standing in their shoes. Insurance companies do not have greater rights to subrogation than accident victims. By doing so, the insurance company will not be obliged to make payments for a loss since it will be placed on the person responsible for it.
Elements of Subrogation
According to California law, an insurance company's cause of action for subrogation consists of the following elements. (a) The insurer suffered a loss for which the defendant bears liability. (b) The loss was not one for which the insurer was primarily responsible. (c) The insurance company compensated the accident victim completely or partially for the same loss that was sustained the defendant is primarily responsible. (d) The insurance company has paid the claim of its policyholder to protect its own interest and not voluntarily. (e) The insurance company has an existing cause of action against the defendant which the accident victim would have been able to assert if it had not been compensated for its loss by the insurance company. (f) The insurance company has paid money resulting from the defendant's liability. (g) Justice requires that the loss be transferred from the insurance company to the defendant. (h) The amount paid to the accident victim, as calculated by the insurance company, can be calculated.
Limits of Subrogation
The insurance company has no subrogation rights against the person who paid for the policy, which means they cannot pay you money and then ask you to pay it back. Subrogation only allows insurance companies to pursue another party. Insured losses are covered by the insurance. The insurance would be worthless if the insurance company could get the money back from you. In an accident in which the policyholder is at fault, there is no subrogation right. Due to the policyholder's actions, he or she cannot sue for compensation. By stepping into the shoes of the policyholder, the insurance company has no one to pursue in order to get their money back.
Subrogation Claim
Subrogation can take three forms. (1) Contractual subrogation arises from the contract between the policyholder and the insurance company. Because it applies only to the contract between you and the insurance company, it is the narrowest form of subrogation. (2) Statutory subrogation laws may give subrogation rights in certain circumstances. This is not as narrow as contractual subrogation because it doesn’t depend on the contract but on the type of relationship between the accident victim and the benefits they are getting. (3) Judges decide cases where equitable subrogation occurs. This is the broadest type of subrogation because your attorney may be able to argue for it in many situations.
Waiving Subrogation Rights
Subrogation efforts made by the insurance company may require your cooperation. There can be no action you take that jeopardizes the insurance company's ability to recover the money it paid you. In exchange for them paying your deductible, you cannot sign an agreement releasing the party at fault. The insurance company will be hurt by this, as they are unable to get their money back.
The Application of Subrogation
Any time a payment was made to someone who was not the primary party responsible, subrogation may apply. Personal injury claims usually involve the following scenarios.
Med Pay Subrogation
Med-Pay is a feature of an auto insurance policy that lets you send your medical bills from an accident to your own insurer for payment. It provides additional funds (beyond comprehensive collision coverage) for medical treatment in the event that you are injured. An insurance company is not required to offer it, however. The two parties negotiate it.
Any reimbursements for medical payments that your insurance company wants must come from the compensation you receive from the at-fault party. The insurance company cannot sue the at-fault party directly for this.
Subrogation In Uninsured Motorist Cases
Under subrogation, an insurance company can obtain reimbursement from the responsible party when paying a claim under your uninsured motorist coverage. Your insurance policy may include a subrogation clause that states: "We (the insurance company) reserve the right to obtain reimbursement from anyone legally responsible for the loss if we make a payment under the uninsured motor vehicle coverage. 'You' (the policyholder) must transfer all recovery rights to us, execute all legal documents we need, and not harm our rights to recover from the responsible party.'" The insurance company is obligated to recover money from the uninsured motorist who caused the accident.
Application to Worker’s Compensation
In California, subrogation applies to workplace injury lawsuits. A worker who suffers a work injury caused by someone else while working has the right to file both a workers' compensation claim and a civil claim. The employer, through its workers' compensation insurance carrier, has the right to sue the person at fault independently or join the lawsuit brought by the injured worker at any time before trial. Workers' compensation insurance companies and injured employees are required to notify each other if the injured employee files a civil lawsuit against a third party. In lieu of joining the matter, the workers' compensation carrier can file a lien. It is possible to update a lien up until the time of judgment if the insurance company continues to pay benefits to the injured worker.
After attorney fees, expenses, and payment of the employer's lien, any funds the injured employee receives from the person who is at fault will relieve the workers' compensation insurance company of having to make further payments to the injured worker until those funds are spent.
Limitations On The Insurance Company’s Subrogation Rights
Subrogation is often at the expense of the accident victim as it reduces the amount she receives from her claim. To prevent settlements from being used up by reimbursing insurance companies who initially made payments before the party at fault pays, there are protections in place.
Health Insurance and Cal. Civ. Code § 3040
Cal. Civ. The purpose of code 3040 is to reduce medical bills associated with personal injury claims. Section 3040 limits what an insurance company can recover from an accident victim's settlement. The insurance company is limited in its recovery by the lesser of (1) the cost of the medical services or; (2) a percentage of the total settlement.
Insurers pay medical providers differently based on how much medical services cost. The concept is known as capitation. Capitation is a set fee that an insurance company pays to a doctor regardless of the services provided. As an alternative, in non-capitated settings, the health insurance company pays doctors according to the services they provide.
Medical providers are paid by some health insurance plans on a capitated basis and by others on a non-capitated basis. For a non-capitated accident victim, it is easy to know what medical care he or she received as a result of the accident since the charges can be used to determine the first factor.
If the insurance company pays a set amount to each patient treated by a doctor, how do you determine how much of that payment was for accident-related medical treatment? According to section 3040, capitated patients are limited to 80% of the usual charge by providers on a non-capitated basis. This allows them to get an idea of the treatment costs for the first factor.
You must take the lower value of the two factors once you determine the cost of the medical services - the first factor. Whether or not an accident victim retained a car accident lawyer is the second factor. A third of the settlement amount is required if they had an attorney. As a second factor, the victim's half of the settlement is used if he or she did not have an attorney.
Made Whole Doctrine
Neither the accident victim nor his insurance company is seeking to collect money from the responsible party. According to the Made Whole Doctrine, an insurance company must be repaid if the settlement has made the victim whole. The issue may arise if the person at fault does not have enough insurance to cover the accident victim's losses.
​
You should know that the Made Whole Doctrine may be overruled by the insurance contract, which gives the insurance company the right to recover as much as they paid.”
If the insurance company does not have its own attorney, it is required to pay a portion of the money it recovers to the accident victim's lawyer.
The Common Fund Doctrine
If the insurance company does not have its own attorney, it must pay part of the money it recovers to the accident victim's attorney. An attorney who is working hard to resolve a case for the accident victim - including recovering funds from the insurance company - should be rewarded for their efforts from the insurer's recovery.
It gives the attorney for the accident victim an incentive to handle the insurance company's subrogation claim. Despite not having hired its own lawyer, the insurance company should still pay some of the cost of getting its money back.
Concepts Similar To Subrogation
Payments made by someone who is not primarily responsible for the payment are referred to as the following terms. Even though they recover a similar amount of money, they are not standing in the shoes of the accident victim.
Contribution
Subrogation is often confused with contribution. However, a person does not step into another's shoes. This is a separate right. One insurer may pay more than the other in the event of two insurance companies defending the same loss. Since both insurers are primarily liable for the loss, they each have the right to ask for compensation from the other if they paid more than their fair share. However, the victim is not affected by this. Nevertheless, even if two insurance companies cover the same policyholder, there may be a subrogation right if one insurer is not primarily responsible.
Reimbursement
You can receive reimbursement if an insurance company has already made a payment. Insurance companies do not have the right to step into the shoes of accident victims, but they do have the right to recover payments from settlements. This is known as reimbursement or subrogation. The subrogation and reimbursement rights of an insurance company are often called subrogation rights in California.
Liens
Liens give the insurance company the right to recover money from a settlement. The settlement will not be paid to the accident victim until the lien is paid.